If you’re a leader, what you believe about people and the kind of creatures we are shapes everything.
I’ve always started from this place: people aren’t lazy. They’re not stupid. They’re not trying to do a bad job. So why do so many organisations treat them as if they are?
We’ve inherited a model of work that’s well past its use-by date. In the early 1900s, Frederick Winslow Taylor made a name for himself with his scientific management theory. Brace yourself for this gem:
“One of the very first requirements for a man who is fit to handle pig iron as a regular occupation is that he shall be so stupid and so phlegmatic that he more nearly resembles in his mental make-up the ox than any other type.”
Charming, right? Yet that’s the foundation modern work was built on.
And while we’ve made huge leaps in technology, we haven’t made the same leap in how we see people at work. Most of us are still swept along by “how things are done around here,” and we rarely pause to challenge the deeper assumptions baked into our work systems.
Because if we evaluate AI’s usefulness against humans stuck in clunky, outdated systems doing average assignment, of course, we’ll think the tech is better. But that comparison misses the point.
Could AI replace a high performing professional?
I was talking with a friend recently about a visit to the GP with her son. Their usual doctor was away, so she had to book whoever was available. The experience? Awful. He didn’t listen, rushed the appointment, and she left feeling more unsure than when they had walked in.
I told her about the time my GP turned to Google mid-consult. When you hear stories like this, it’s tempting to think, “Maybe an AI doctor would be better.”
But here’s the thing.
Sure, AI might outperform a poorly performing GP. But could it ever replace a high performing GP? Someone who brings together clinical knowledge with empathy, care, and connection? Not a chance. So instead of asking, “Could AI replace this underperforming human?”, we need to ask deeper questions:
How do we get GPs to perform and feel at their best?
What is the role of AI in supporting patients? What can it do better than a high performing human?
What parts of a GP’s job are always going to be performed better by humans?
What shifts need to be made to the system that GPs are in to support patient care?
As a leader in your organisation, how might you ask yourself these similar questions? And how might you use them to have deeper conversations with your leadership team?
To even start these conversations, there’s a bridge to cross. Trust. When I’m working with leadership teams, I’ll often ask: what’s your default setting when it comes to trust? Do you trust people from the outset, or do they have to prove themselves first? Pause for a moment. What’s your answer? And does it change depending on the context you’re in?
It’s a fascinating question, and one that shows up everywhere, especially in how we design systems. Because when we design organisations that assume people can’t be trusted or need constant oversight, we create environments where people disengage. And then we wonder why motivation and performance fall through the floor.
But what if we flipped the script? What if we started from the belief that humans are high performing (or at least want to be), and that with the right conditions, support, and challenge, they can get there?
This is where my obsession with human performance kicks in. I still remember the moment I read this passage from Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi’s seminal book Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience:
“The best moments in our lives are not the passive, receptive, relaxing times, although such experiences can also be enjoyable if we have worked hard to attain them. The best moments usually occur when a person’s body or mind is stretched to its limits in a voluntary effort to accomplish something difficult and worthwhile. Optimal experience is thus something that we make happen. For a child, it could be placing with trembling fingers the last block on a tower she has built, higher than any she has built so far. For a swimmer, it could be trying to beat his own record. For a violinist, mastering an intricate musical passage. For each person, there are thousands of opportunities, challenges to expand ourselves.”
This hit me in the gut. People aren’t wired to avoid effort. We’re wired to engage, but only when it’s something that matters and when we have the chance to do it well.
This is where the design piece comes in. If we want better performance, we don’t need to replace people. We need to design better systems. Systems that create the conditions for people to do their best work.
Three psychological needs that drive performance
In my work in creating high performing workplaces where people love to work, I use Self-Determination Theory a lot. This research has been around since the 1970s and is grounded in three psychological needs that drive performance and wellbeing: autonomy, competence, and relatedness.
Autonomy is about having control over what you do and how you do it. It’s not about working alone or just doing whatever you want. It’s more that your decisions are self-directed rather than imposed.
Competence is the sense that we can handle what is in front of us. That we have the skills, knowledge, and confidence to meet challenges and make progress. People have a need to build their competence and develop mastery over things that are important to them over time.
Relatedness is our human need for connection. To feel seen, supported, and valued by others. In work and life, people flourish when they feel part of a group, a team, a cause, or a community. The fact is we need other people to be at our best.
When these three needs are met, people don’t just perform better. They feel better. They show up differently. And the results of the organisation are the byproduct.
What is next?
So, how do we begin creating the kind of work environment that supports this?
One powerful way that I have done this with my clients is to combine Self-Determination Theory with the practice of Job Crafting, the idea that people can actively shape how they experience their work.
It’s not about rewriting job descriptions. It’s about making small but meaningful adjustments to how people approach their tasks, use their strengths, and connect with others. It gives people the agency to bring more purpose and energy into the work they’re already doing.
This isn’t just a strategy for senior professionals with flexible roles. In fact, some of the most compelling examples come from jobs where people are typically given very little say in how their work is done.
Organisational psychologist Amy Wrzesniewski has studied hospital cleaners who go beyond their assigned tasks, taking time to comfort patients, rearranging art on the walls to lift someone’s spirits, or anticipating the needs of nurses and doctors to make the ward run more smoothly.
These aren’t duties listed in a position description. But they are acts of purpose, autonomy, care, and connection.
They are ways of crafting the role to meet human needs, both their own and others.
Job Crafting works because it can tap directly into those three core psychological needs.
Autonomy grows when people feel trusted to shape how they work.
Competence builds when they pursue tasks that stretch and develop them.
Relatedness deepens when they choose to connect with others in ways that feel authentic and meaningful.
When leaders create space for this kind of work, they send a powerful signal. We don’t just want you to do the job. We want you to make it yours. We trust that you’ll do that in ways that benefit both you and the people around you.
If we want high performing workplaces, and we want to meet the challenges of AI in the future of work, we have to start with a foundational principle.
People want to do good work. Then design for it. That’s how we create workplaces where humans perform at their very best.
Doing this kind of work is not easy. It means questioning assumptions, challenging legacy systems, and navigating organisational resistance, often from the very structures meant to support performance. In many organisations, pushing for change like this can feel almost impossible. That’s why people bring me in. I help facilitate the conversations that need to happen.
I bring a lens grounded in science and experience, with a track record of shifting teams and systems in ways that last. You could go it alone. But sometimes, it’s easier and more effective with someone walking alongside you.
If that’s something you’d like to explore further, send me an email at hello@alexbakowski.com. I’d love to hear where you’re at.


